Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker Review: RecoGuru Analysis & User Insights
In-depth review of the Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker. Analyzing features, 16,000+ user reviews, pros & cons. Is it worth it? Find out.

Quick Look: At a Glance
- Ice Production
- Up to 26 lbs per day
- Ice Cube Size
- Choice of two sizes
- Ice Making Time
- Ready in 6 minutes
- Capacity
- Stores up to 2.2 lbs of ice
- Design
- Stainless steel with transparent window
- Overall Rating
- (16,000+ ratings) See Breakdown 4.4 / 5
- Price (New)
- $75.59 (Subject to change)
- Price (Used)
- From $45.41 (Very Good)
Over 600+ bought bought recently!
Deep Dive: Features & Specifications
The Frigidaire EFIC189 Compact Ice Maker offers a convenient solution for on-demand ice production.
- Large Capacity: Produces up to 26 lbs of clear ice cubes per day.
- Efficient & Easy to Use: Makes ice cubes in less than 6 minutes and stores up to 2.2 lbs at a time. User-friendly electronic controls.
- Versatile: Offers a choice of two different ice cube sizes.
- Modern Design: Stainless steel ice maker with a large transparent window.
- Functionality: Digital control panel indicates when the bin is full and when the water is empty.
Product Description: The Frigidaire EFIC189 is a compact ice maker designed for home use. It efficiently produces ice in a short amount of time, making it ideal for small gatherings or everyday use. The choice of ice cube sizes adds versatility, while the transparent window allows you to monitor ice production. User reviews highlight its ease of use and speed, although some mention concerns about long-term durability. Overall, it provides a practical way to ensure a constant supply of ice without the need for a bulky freezer ice maker.
User Review Analysis (Based on 16,000+ Reviews)
Based on over 16,000 customer reviews, here's a breakdown of common themes:
👍The Positive Reviews (72% 5-Star)
- Many users find the ice maker easy to use and set up.
- Customers appreciate the speed at which the ice maker produces ice.
- Several reviewers mention that the ice maker is a great value for the price.
- Users like the convenience of having ice on demand without needing a freezer ice maker.
👎Common Criticisms
- Some users reported that the ice maker stopped working after a few months.
- The ice melts faster than ice from a freezer.
- Some users find the machine to be noisy.
- A few users have experienced rusting of internal components.
Pros & Cons Summary
➕Pros
- Makes ice quickly (within 6 minutes)
- Compact design fits easily on countertops
- Easy to use with straightforward electronic controls
- Offers a choice of two different ice cube sizes
- Provides a constant source of ice without a freezer ice maker
- Good value for money, saving on ice purchases
➖Cons
- Potential for rusting stems if not properly maintained
- Ice is not as dense and melts faster than traditional ice
- Some users report the unit stops working after a short period
- Small ice holding tray may require frequent emptying
- Can be noisy during operation
Available Options & Pricing
This review focuses on the Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker (ASIN: B075QP7SCP). Other color options may be available:
- Color: Black, Silver
- Buying Options: Typically available 'New' (around $75.59) and sometimes 'Used' (check listings starting from $45.41). Prices may vary.
Current Availability: In Stock. New & Used (3) from $45.41 & FREE Shipping.
Who Should Buy the FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Silver?
This product is a great fit for:
- Individuals who need a portable ice maker for small spaces.
- People who want ice on demand without a built-in freezer ice maker.
- Those looking for a convenient and easy-to-use ice-making solution.
- Users who want to save money on buying bags of ice.
If you need a large quantity of ice for large events or require ice that lasts a very long time, this compact ice maker may not be suitable.
⚖️ The RecoGuru Verdict
The Frigidaire EFIC189 Compact Ice Maker is a convenient and efficient solution for quickly producing ice. Its compact design and ease of use make it a good choice for small gatherings or personal use. The ability to choose between two ice cube sizes adds to its versatility.
However, potential buyers should be aware of some reported issues with long-term durability and the fact that the ice melts faster than traditional ice. Regular cleaning and maintenance are essential to prevent rusting.
Recommended for those who need a portable and easy-to-use ice maker for everyday use or small gatherings. Consider alternatives if you require a large quantity of ice or need it to last for extended periods.
Ready to Make Your Decision?
Check it out for yourself!
🛒 Buy the FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, 26 lb per Day, Silver (Silver) on Amazon