LP on LP 05 (Twist / Stash Uniondale, NY 4/2/98) (Vinyl, February 7, 2025)

Quick Look: At a Glance

Overall Rating: ★★★⯨☆ 3.6 / 5 See Breakdown

Artist: Phish
Format: Vinyl
Release Date: February 7, 2025
Tracks: Twist / Stash

Price (New): $15.08 (Subject to change)
Price (Used): From $16.58

Over 50+ bought bought recently!

⚖️ The Recoguru Verdict

The Phish LP on LP 05 offers a glimpse into the band's Island Tour, capturing live performances of 'Twist' and 'Stash.' However, potential buyers should be aware of reported sound quality issues.

User reviews suggest that the vinyl may suffer from sibilance and surface noise, detracting from the listening experience.

Recommended for dedicated Phish fans who are willing to overlook potential audio imperfections. Consider alternative sources if sound quality is a top priority.

Pros & Cons Summary

➕Pros

Features live recordings from Phish's Island Tour.
Showcases the 'Twist' and 'Stash' performances from Nassau Coliseum.
Mixed by Vance Powell.

➖Cons

Potential for poor sound quality (sibilance, surface noise) reported by some users.
Limited track selection (only two songs).
May not appeal to casual Phish fans.

Deep Dive: Features & Specifications

LP on LP 05 captures the exploratory feel of Phish's Island Tour with two standout tracks.

Features two tracks from Phish's Island Tour: Twist and Stash recorded live at Nassau Coliseum, NY on 4/2/98.
Side A showcases the deep-space Island Twist from set II, exploring intergalactic territory with a bass nod to Star Trek.
Side B features Stash from set I, a dark jam that erupts into staccato melody and an ambient outro.
Recorded by Paul Languedoc and mixed from the multitrack masters by Vance Powell.

This vinyl release features two tracks, 'Twist' and 'Stash,' from Phish's Island Tour stop in Uniondale, NY. While the performances themselves are noteworthy, some user reviews point to potential issues with the vinyl's sound quality. Be aware of possible sibilance and surface noise before purchasing.

User Review Analysis

Here's a summary of common themes found in user reviews:

👍The Positive Reviews (60% 5-Star)

Some users appreciate the music itself, despite the sound quality issues.

👎Common Criticisms

Poor sound quality reported by multiple users, including sibilance and surface noise.
One user described the sound on side A as horrible, especially the vocals.
Some users expressed disappointment that Phish doesn't do a better job with this LP on LP series.